The Opt-Out Nation

A small house with a green roof sits alone on a barren hill, surrounded by dry grass and sparse shrubs under a partly cloudy sky.

Print Issue

Summer 2026

The Opt-Out Nation

Stories of American exit in the nation's 250th year.

Photo by David Blakeman

The United States was founded on opting out: of the Church of England, of monarchy, of the idea that rights are inherited rather than self-evident. That instinct lived on. Modern Americans are leaving churches, colleges, and cities at high rates. The share of U.S. adults who call themselves political independents has never been higher. And for better or worse, the second Trump administration has made opting out of longstanding agreements — treaties, alliances, institutions — de facto policy. This issue is a collection of stories about that American instinct to opt out, to pack up and go, to tell the boss, “I’d prefer not to.” We hope you enjoy reading it — maybe on a night when you decide to turn down plans and stay home.

—The Editors

Magazine cover titled "BIG THINK" with the headline "Greetings from THE Opt-Out Nation" over a landscape of hills and a solitary house under a blue sky.

This issue available in print!

Interested in quarterly print issues? Become a member.

FRONT OF BOOK

The Amish constitute America’s largest-scale experiment with opting out of modern society — and judging by the numbers, it’s a very successful one.

Frank Jacobs

Before, I didn't know how to use a drill. Now I can apart take a diesel heater and service it within an hour or two.

Jasna Hodžić

If the U.S. itself is the opt-out nation, transcendentalism is the opt-out philosophy.

Jonny Thomson
FEATURES

Everyone I spoke to in Cochise County was a graduate of “YouTube University,” having learned about building an earthbag home from videos online.

Chandler Fritz

Even where they stay, what the U.S. is saying is, 'We're using our leverage to get you to work the way we want.'

Céline Kauffmann

Inside that swarm, minds a trillion or more times as complex as humanity think thoughts as far beyond human imagination as a microprocessor is beyond a nematode worm.

Thomas Moynihan

The people who get to the top positions of power — these are not people who demonstrated fantastic leadership skills.

Dan Carlin
BACK OF BOOK

Two-thirds of Gen Z report feeling nostalgic for eras before their lifetime.

Clay Routledge

Crisis has a way of burning off the unnecessary and leaving behind only what was always true.

Eric Markowitz

Trauma and the frustrations of modern life can motivate a retreat to nature, but abstaining from society still feels, on some level, like capitulation.

Henry Eliot

The hidden cost of AI in schools: fewer moments of doubt

Philosopher Gert Biesta on the real reason we should be wary of AI in education.

The myth of a shared reality

In conversation with Kmele Foster, Dan Carlin unpacks the myth of shared reality, the erosion of society, and the history that preceded it.

As print literacy fades, our perception of truth is warping

The printing press gave us objective truth. Social media made truth tribal again. AI could make it something else entirely.

America pioneered gravitational wave research. Now it may leave it behind.

The LIGO facilities in the U.S. are the most sensitive gravitational wave detectors in the world. Their future remains uncertain.